The Characteristics of an Alternative Lender

عربي


In a recent article, this column laid out the case for the rise of the alternative lender as a natural consequence to the hole left by conventional banks withdrawing from the SME market. This article looks at what a successful alternative lender might look like.

The first step is to understand the relevant characteristics of a conventional SME lender. Conventional banks are, by and large, mature companies with an inflexible and conforming operating culture. This leads to risk rigidity, i.e. banks will usually get comfortable at one point of the risk curve and they will rarely leave it.

This in turn leads to product concentration and possibly myopia at the macro level with innovation only at the micro level. What this means is that the basic types of products do not change, so a salary loan will pretty much be the same at all the banks in terms of tenor and structure. One bank might add a lottery to the loan, another bank might allow deferral of one payment per year, but overall they are the same.

Continue reading

Moral Arbitrage and the Inheritance Play

The thing about the rational investor hypothesis is that it assumes that investors wish to maximise a financial risk/reward function. They don’t. Investors have a utility function that includes economic considerations, but also includes many other goals important to the investor.

Some investors may refuse to invest in defense companies, especially those that produce offensive weapons. Others may avoid investing in companies based in countries who have policies that they don’t approve of. Still others may reject gambling or alcohol related companies. The list goes on.

Whilst economists discuss such issues ad nauseam, traders make money off it. A non-financially motivated seller nearly always provides an opportunity for the astute, and differently motivated, investor to make money.

Continue reading

The Hidden Motivation of Entrepreneurs

People usually misunderstand what it means to be an entrepreneur (read: The Meaning of Entrepreneurship). One of the most difficult issues that they face is their own motivation. The first time entrepreneur usually believes that his primary motivation is commercial. Their actions usually prove that commercial goals are low priority. This schizophrenia causes unnecessary stress to the entrepreneurs and value destruction to the company. Continue reading

The Poetry of Entrepreneurship

A well rounded education, formal or informal, is necessary for the success of any entrepreneur. The internet is replete with quotes relevant to the entrepreneur. But the world has offered much more, oh so much more, to the inquisitive mind. Yes, Malcom Gladwell has interesting insights, a look into Steve Job’s life might be beneficial, and maybe you can really learn to work for only four hours a week.

But all of this misses the power of words that connect with you emotionally, at a deep level. The spirit must receive the same nourishment as the mind and body, and what better than the world’s leading poets to provide such nourishment? Who better to capture the spirit of the challenge, the journey, that is an entrepreneur?

Continue reading

The Investor’s Edge

Many of the ideas used by the investment community are adopted from the horse track and casino betting communities. Much of the failure that has dogged the investment community is due to rocket scientist PhDs misunderstanding the successful models of plebeian punters. The use of betting as an example is not an endorsement, just history.

To understand how the securities markets work you have to look no further than the horse bookies. Bookies take the bets from the bettors. This is the first point that the public begins to misunderstand how betting, and therefore investing, works.

There are two potential misunderstandings: The first misunderstanding is assuming that each horse has a uniform probability of winning, i.e. they are all just as likely to win. The second misunderstanding is assuming that the bookie offers one to one payout odds, i.e. pays $1 for each $1 that is bet. Grasping the significance of these statements is the key to successful investing.

The bookie, equivalent to the investment bank or broker, will always make money. Always. They do this because they do not set payout odds depending on which horse they think will win, they set payout odds based on how people bet.

Continue reading

Second Order Questions and Sterilising the Oil Price Effect

Consider, if you will, an oil exporting nation. Consider further those nations whose commodity exports far exceed their budgetary needs. What is a nation to do with such excess wealth?

There are two main approaches to this. The first is the more conventional strategy inherited from central banks, in many ways the precursors to SWFs. This method, which I will call risk-off, seeks simply to hold foreign exchange reserves, usually the US dollar, in the form of high quality, low risk assets, usually US Treasury bonds.

The second strategy, which I will call the risk-on, borrows heavily from pension and endowment funds. Investments are made not to protect value, but to create value so as to meet future obligations. Not only is public equity as an asset class targeted, but all manner of alternative investments including but not restricted to private equity, hedge funds, real estate and high yield debt.

So as not to confuse the point that I am trying to make, I would like to clarify that there is no right or wrong to which method a government chooses, as the choice is driven by policy considerations not investment considerations.

Back to our story. If an oil exporting country with a risk-on strategy suddenly faced oil prices dropping by 50%, what is the net effect to its revenue? Using Norway as an example, their circa 1.7 million barrels per day of export would lose USD 85 million per day in revenue or USD 31 billion per year.

Continue reading

Trading Insights: Exposing the St. Petersburg Paradox

The St. Petersburg Paradox is a famous problem in probability and economics. The problem states that a coin is repeatedly flipped. The bet starts with $2. Every time a tails shows up, the bet is doubled. The first time a heads shows up the game ends and you receive the current bet from the ‘house’. The question is, how much would you pay the house for such a game?

From a probability point of view, the expected payout is infinite, and it is not hard to see why: the payout is doubled each round. This leads us to the paradox: you should be willing to pay an infinite amount to play this game. Most people would refuse to.

Continue reading

The Intricacies of a Productive Economy

From the point of view of a national economy, what does it mean to be a successful company? Is it contribution to GDP?

GDP is an attempt at measuring the production of an economy. It is not an efficiency measure, but a measure of overall economic strength.

GDP is of course difficult to measure. First, how does one collect the necessary information? In most countries the tax authority can provide this information since all commercial transactions must be reported to the authority. In the UAE there is no such authority and this creates a challenge.

Continue reading

The Breeding and Nurturing of Ideas

I must own up to something. I am not a prolific writer. I get that compliment quite often by readers of my articles. But I do not produce 3 to 5 major ideas a week. I harvest them.

What do I mean when I say that I harvest my ideas? Nobody can come up with so many ideas on a consistent basis. My ideas did not form in the days before I wrote an article. They formed over the period of my professional career, and even before that. And when I needed them, either to do my job or to write an article, well there they were.

Continue reading