Dismantling GCC Monopolies for a more Efficient Economy

A good rule of life is that there is no free lunch. The examples offered as proof to the contrary are simply misunderstood as they are pure luck, which would be clear if the many comparative failures are also taken into account. In a country – indeed a region – that has had meteoric growth over the past half-century, far too many participants seem to have confused a long-term economic bull market with corporate success.

To use the vernacular of investors, there was no alpha, which is value creation by individual companies, and it was all beta, which is company growth due to growth of the economy.

Continue reading

Broken Arrow: A Tightening Economy and Short on Hope

In the Vietnam War movie We Were Soldiers, depicting the first major battle the Americans had in that conflict, the leader of the US soldiers Lt Colonel Hal Moore, played by Mel Gibson, stands up in the middle of battle and looks around.

What he sees is chaos, his men dying and the enemy about to overrun his position.

Hal Moore then nods to himself as if making a decision and transmits the code phrase “Broken Arrow”. It basically meant ”we’re in trouble”, and every US military aircraft diverted from its mission to support the ground forces.

In many ways I feel the same from an investment and business point of view. I look at oil and it is US$33 per barrel and heading lower as Iran ramps up its production. Add to that Saudi Arabia’s promise to not cut production and it seems that $20 oil, or lower, is here to stay. Continue reading

The GCC's Pension Funding Challenges and Silver Linings

The effect of demographics on the economy has been one of increasing concern for countries with ageing populations. The poster child for this issue is Japan although an increasing number of countries in the Western Hemisphere are beginning to take notice as well. The main issue is that declining population growth rates and in some cases negative population growth rates are severely challenging the historical funding of retirees with tax revenue collected from a working population that is greater in number.

Continue reading

How Interest Rates Will Affect the UAE

The Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) of the United States Federal Reserve recently decided not to increase interest rates. This is significant because US interest rates affect not only the economy of the US but every single economy in the world in quite a material way.

Much of the analysis on how the actions of the FOMC will affect the UAE’s economy mirror the analysis for emerging markets as a whole. There is much one can learn by looking at other economies but emerging economies are not identical to each other and each has unique characteristics that simply do not fall within the norms of the emerging markets as a whole.

Continue reading

Greece's Problem is that the European Union is Speaking Greek

The language used in discussing Greece’s economic dilemma is getting in the way of a solution. In business negotiations it is usually quite useful to look at the major issues and try to reframe them. This is no different when talking about economies.

Issue 1: The Greeks “rejected austerity.”

Reframe 1: The Greeks rejected the controlled austerity offered by the EU in favour of the chaos that the current Greek government has ensured for its citizens. This reframe is extremely important as the structure of the Greek government’s referendum was negligent and potentially fraudulent: they did not offer their citizens an explicit choice between two courses of action, instead they allowed one of the choices to be implicit. By doing so the Greek government betrayed their own people by hiding the risks from them.

What comes out of this reframe is that the gap in reality as understood by the Greek government and its citizens needs to be narrowed and even eradicated. This will take a lot of courage from the Greek government.

Continue reading

Dear Forbes: Dubai is more than alcohol and bikinis on the beach

A recent article in Forbes asks whether the Dubai government is entrepreneurial in nature and if so whether the government is more entrepreneurial than the people. These are important points to consider and are a frequent topic of conversation. Unfortunately the Forbes article got it wrong.

The article lists four points as to why the Dubai government is entrepreneurial. I will rebut each one and then make my argument as to what is happening.

Continue reading

UAE Labour Policy and the Health of the Economy: Ying & Yang

The phrase “UAE dependence on foreign labour” is a mainstay of any discussion about the UAE’s economy. It sounds self-evident, doesn’t it? I, however, refuse to believe an opinion that is stated as fact, regardless of how authoritative the statement might sound.

The implication in the statement is that if foreign labour were to leave the UAE then the economy of the UAE would be negatively impacted. This misses the point that the factors affecting an economy are many, and are dynamic. For example, the statement does not address how easy to it is to replace labour. But that is for another article.

In this article I’ll look at what the relationship between foreign labour and the economy are, which of these leads and which of them follows and what this means to the UAE.

So how should we investigate this? I have heard it said that a picture is worth a thousand word. Let me present three.

Source: The World Bank

Source: The World Bank

Continue reading

The Intricacies of a Productive Economy

From the point of view of a national economy, what does it mean to be a successful company? Is it contribution to GDP?

GDP is an attempt at measuring the production of an economy. It is not an efficiency measure, but a measure of overall economic strength.

GDP is of course difficult to measure. First, how does one collect the necessary information? In most countries the tax authority can provide this information since all commercial transactions must be reported to the authority. In the UAE there is no such authority and this creates a challenge.

Continue reading

Saudi Oil Price Redux

In an earlier article I corrected some common misconceptions on what is happening with oil prices and how it affects the economy. This generated some feedback and further questions that I will address in this article. In particular I will focus on understanding the role of a cartel, the long term incentives of an oil producer and why oil prices have risen.

Let’s start with the concept that OPEC is a cartel. It isn’t because it lacks a major feature of a successful cartel: legal enforceability of quotas. To understand OPEC’s actual role in the history of oil, you need to start with the Texas Railroad Commission (‘TRC’). The TRC is the original cartel that controlled global oil prices and was an agency of the State of Texas that controlled up to 40% of US production until the late 1950s. Their power was derived from an oil production boom that saw prices plummet and Texas oilmen demand a cartel system of enforced quotas. The TRC served as a model for OPEC. The irony is not lost upon this writer. Continue reading

Saudi Oil Price, the Global Economy and Correcting Media Economists

The hysteria surrounding Saudi Arabia’s increase in oil production and a subsequent drop in oil price to the mid-eighties and possibly lower is non-sensical. It’s nearly as bad a media reaction as if oil prices had moved the same amount upwards. Reports in the media have focussed on the possible political machinations of such a ‘dastardly’ move and the economic effect on oil producing countries not least of which is Saudi Arabia. Personally, the first thing that comes to my mind is that oil has dropped around 30% in the last few months and that is great news for the global economy and the world’s population. Why aren’t people rejoicing?

Continue reading